MARY KLUK GALA DINNER 2013Parliament Hijacked for Anti-Israel Propaganda Stunt

At time writing, we are following up with various government and party leaders regarding the “Solidarity Conference in support of the people of Palestine, Cuba and Western Sahara”, which took place in Parliament last week under the auspices of the International Relations and Cooperation Portfolio Committee. To date, this event has attracted little media attention, and it is not known at this stage whether it will have any impact on existing government policy regarding the South Africa-Israel relationship. Last year, Cabinet issued a statement reiterating its long-standing position, namely that it recognises the right of both Israelis and Palestinians to their own sovereign states co-existing side by side with one another and to this end supporting the efforts by the two peoples to find a negotiated solution to the conflict between them. It also confirmed that no ‘travel ban’ had been imposed on government officials wanting to visit Israel.

The discussions and outcomes at last week’s event unfortunately bore little relation to this essentially balanced and realistic stand-point on the part of the government. This was hardly surprising as without exception, those chosen to participate are well known anti-Israel activists. Several also have a record of making overtly antisemitic statements, amongst them Fatima Hajaig (who once claimed that the West is in thrall to Jewish money power) and COSATU’s Bongani Masuku, whose threats against the Jewish resulted in a SA Human Rights Commission hate speech ruling against him. Neither the Israeli Embassy nor the Jewish leadership was invited to give the Israeli perspective. Instead, the entire discussion around the Israel-Palestine question was so framed as to provide a platform for anti-Israel activists to make vitriolic attacks on Israel without being challenged. There was no discussion on how to advance the peace process, but plenty of over-the-top rhetoric culminating in a host of recommendations calling for Israel to be boycotted. We note that ACDP was the only political party present to protest against the grossly one-sided nature of the event. One of our primary concerns is how Parliament, which represents more than any other forum a public space where all views on a particular issue can be aired, was allowed to become a propaganda vehicle for a narrowly focused special interest group.

Countdown to Elections, 2014

While not yet officially confirmed, 7 May has now been settled on as the date of the national and provincial elections. Over the next three months, as previously reported, the Board will be running a range of projects to stimulate Jewish interest and involvement in the elections, including hosting public debates between some of the competing political parties and introducing our community to what those parties stand for. Now that we have an election date to work from, we are in the process of organising these events, and will keep the community informed once details have been finalised. Another important project we are involved with is in putting together a team of volunteers to act as election monitors on the day, and thus far the response from our community has been very encouraging. We were also pleased to note the excellent response to our registration drive, through which many additional community members have ensured that they are properly registered on the voters’ roll. Exciting times lie ahead, so watch this space!

Mary Kluk
National Chairman, SAJBD

Listen to SAJBD “JEWISH BOARD TALK” with Charisse ……



A definite low point last year was the disruption by anti-Israel demonstrators of a piano recital by Yossi Reshef on Wits University campus. This was a flagrant violation of the right to freedom of expression and association of those attending, as well as being in overt violation of the universities own code of conduct and academic principles. For the sake of our Jewish students, and indeed for the entire Wits community, it was imperative that the University take appropriate steps to deal with this incident. It was unthinkable that a situation be allowed to emerge in which particular lobby groups could silence with impunity anyone they disagreed with.

Fortunately, the Wits leadership unequivocally condemned the incident and took decisive steps to deal with it. This included hosting a highly successful follow-up concert by an Israeli jazz quartet to demonstrate Wits’ commitment to ensuring safe spaces for all forms of expression. The most critical part of Wits response, however, was to conduct a thorough investigation into what took place and institute disciplinary proceedings against those responsible. This was done, with charges of misconduct being levelled at eleven students (nine of them members of the Student Representative Council). There were angry protests and much pressure was brought to bear by certain student groups and trade union bodies to drop the charges, but the disciplinary process was scrupulously followed through at every stage as per University regulations.

Last week, following a lengthy process of information gathering and formal hearings, Wits announced its verdict. In summary, ten of the students charged were found guilty of misconduct. The sanction imposed was that they be excluded from the university for one year, suspended provided that they not be found guilty of other forms of misconduct for two years, that none be allowed to hold office in any student government structure during that period and that each must perform 80 hours of community service.

Ensuring the safety and well-being of our university students is a priority for the Jewish communal leadership, as indeed it is for all communities in South Africa. It is vital that our campuses provide a safe environment in which the widest range of ideas and beliefs can be expressed, and that no student or faculty member be in any way victimised or censored for their views. This is why the decision by Wits was so important, not only in terms of what it means for Jewish students, but for the way it has reaffirmed the University’s commitment to upholding academic freedom, equality and diversity.

In a press statement welcoming the decision, the Board commended Wits for the firm stand it had taken against those who abuse their right to protest by flouting the principles of academic freedom and seeking to silence alternative viewpoints. The outcome of the disciplinary process had sent a clear message that Wits remains a free, open environment in which the values of freedom of expression and association are strenuously upheld and where any behaviour aimed at preventing others from exercising those rights is not tolerated. Our statement concluded with the hope that the decision will usher in a new era of mutual respect, trust and openness on Wits campus, one that provides safe spaces for the expression of diverse opinions and where people of differing viewpoints can learn from rather than try to silence one another.









Listen to Charisse Zeifert on Jewish Board Talk, 101.9 ChaiFM every Friday 12:00-13:00.



Chanukah, which commences this week, represents amongst other things the resilience of the Jewish people in maintaining their religious and cultural identity under the most difficult circumstances. Historically, Jews have been subjected to all kinds of challenges that have threatened to separate them from their heritage. At worst, this has taken the form of outright religious persecution, as was the case in the time of the Maccabees and at various other times subsequent to that. A more insidious form of pressure, which is what primarily faces Diaspora Jewry today, is that of quiet assimilation into the host culture. This, too, had to be overcome by our ancestors during the period of Greek overlordship, given how very powerful and enticing was the dominant Greek of the day.


Chanukah differs from the other festivals in having an overtly public aspect to the way in which its central ritual, the lighting of the candles, is observed. Once lit, those lights have to be displayed in such a way as to be visible from the outside the Jewish home. As such, they represent an unabashed assertion of one’s Jewish identity. In South Africa, this also takes the form of celebrations in such public venues as shopping centres, often featuring the lighting of a giant chanukiah.

For many younger members of our community, the lessons of Chanukah have a particular resonance around this time. The festival always follows close on the writing of matric exams by Jewish high school students, who find themselves on the threshold of a new and challenging period of their lives as independent young adults. One of the great strengths of South African Jewry is that more than four out of five of its children attend a Jewish day school. While the benefits of this in fostering an enduring Jewish identity are obvious, it does also mean that when they leave school, most of our youth will be exposed to a predominantly non-Jewish environment for the first time. For them, their continued identification with the Jewish community will henceforth be a matter of personal choice. In wishing our matriculants all success in their future endeavours, I also strongly encourage them to find ways to remain connected to Jewish communal affairs. In particular, I urge new students to join the SA Union of Jewish Students and get involved in the many diverse projects and activities it provides.

The annual end-of-year youth camps will be commencing shortly. An essential aspect of organising these events is ensuring that the camps are properly secured. Here, the CSO continues to do an outstanding job in maintaining a rigorous and thorough 24-hour protection against all conceivable threats. It is able to discharge this vital task, along with many more of its core functions, in large part through its volunteer base. This is another important area where our youth can make a meaningful contribution, and indeed the effectiveness of the CSO since its inception can to a considerable extent be attributed to the young men and women who have given of their time to be part of it.

In conclusion, I wish our class of 2013 everything of the best in this exciting new phase of their lives, and look forward to their future contribution to and involvement in the Jewish community and its activities.

• Listen to Charisse Zeifert on Jewish Board Talk, 101.9 ChaiFM every Friday 12:00-13:00.


The secular year is drawing to a close with a flurry of communal events, whether relating to civil society activities, Holocaust commemoration, the forthcoming Chanukah festivities and inter-faith initiatives. The Board has been, and continues to be involved with these, in partnership with other Jewish organisations as well as with organisations outside the Jewish communal fold.

In my last column, I reported on the very moving events commemorating the start of the Holocaust in Hungary and the 75th anniversary of Kristallnacht, organised in collaboration with the Johannesburg Holocaust and Genocide Centre and the relevant embassies. During that time, we also worked closely with the SA Union of Jewish Students in a nation-wide voter registration awareness campaign for next year’s elections. More recently, we became involved on behalf of Chabad in resolving certain problems that had arisen regarding its forthcoming Chanukah celebration, to take place at Sandton City on 1 December.

Other events in December in which the Board is involved are the annual interfaith Reconciliation Day Walk in Cape Town and a commemorative event to mark the yahrtzeit of a great Jewish philanthropist at the Great Park Synagogue in Johannesburg. The Cape Council of the Board has played a pivotal role in organising the walk, in tandem with leaders of other faith groups in the city. Participants traditionally gather outside the St George’s Cathedral and from there proceed to the Gardens shul and finally to the Auwal Mosque. At each stop they are addressed on topics relevant to the theme of reconciliation and understanding between different groupings by religious and civic leaders.

At the Great Park, descendants of the so-called ‘Ochberg Orphans’ will come together to recite Kaddish in memory of Isaac Ochberg, whose efforts and personal heroism saw some 200 Jewish orphans being brought to South Africa from Eastern Europe after World War I. The memorial function will give some of the descendants of these children an opportunity to repay in some part this inestimable debt they owe this great man. Afterwards, several of the participants will speak about Isaac Ochberg and his legacy. The Board has been involved in planning and publicising the event, and our Associate Director David Saks will be one of the speakers. For more information, contact Rabbi Shaun Wingrin on 082-449-6273/

What all of the above have in common, as already noted, is that they were or are being put together in collaboration with a variety of other organisations and/or individuals. The latter represent a range of different interests, from the religious through to those with a human rights, youth, civil society or political focus. This underlines how the Board sees itself, namely as a broad tent that facilitates and involves itself in the complete spectrum of Jewish life in partnership with its constituent bodies. I am pleased to report that we have just appointed two new staff members, Aviva Moses and Janine Shamos, whose respective backgrounds in, amongst other things, women’s rights and international liaison, have provided us with additional capacity to extend our range in the services we provide to our Jewish community.

MARY KLUKListen to Charisse Zeifert on Jewish Board Talk, 101.9 ChaiFM every Friday 12:00-13:00.


S. Africa would be wise to ponder its Israel stance

4 November 2013

      The recent disclosure by South Africa‘s International Relations Minister Maite Nkoana-Mashabane that her country would be cooling relations with Israel, comes as no surprise. For years now Pretoria’s formal policy has been to back the Palestinian right to self-determination, while simultaneously supporting Israel’s right to exist. But in practice, as the Israeli-Palestinian [...]

[read more]


1 November 2013

A continual challenge for the Jewish community leadership is to combine addressing the internal needs of our Jewish community with helping Jews to also identify with and contribute to the greater national debate in South Africa. In this regard the SAJBD, in addition to pursuing its core mandate of upholding Jewish civil rights, encourages and [...]

[read more]

MARY KLUK ABOVE BOARD : 25 October 2013

24 October 2013

Creating ‘Safe Spaces’ for debate and dialogue I would like to begin this week’s column by congratulating the newly elected executive of the SAJBD Cape Council, whose members were elected shortly after the SAJBD Cape conference held earlier this month. It comprises Gary Eisenberg (chairman), Stanley Donen and Eric Marx (vice-chairmen), Vivienne Anstey and Lester [...]

[read more]

Mary Kluk Above Board 11/10/2013

11 October 2013

We have come to expect robust, challenging and diverse debate at the biennial Cape Board conferences, and the latest such gathering, held over the weekend, more than lived up to those expectations. As indicated by its theme of ‘Safe Spaces’, it was about the Board acting as a truly representative forum allowing for as broad [...]

[read more]

Mary Kluk Above Board, 4 October 2013

4 October 2013

We have just come out of an exhilarating three-week period of Chagim, one commencing with the solemnity of Rosh Hashanah and culminating in the exuberance of Simchat Torah. Life for most of us got back to ‘normal’ this week, albeit, one hopes, with a renewed sense of energy and positivity that those times of introspection, [...]

[read more]

Board Bids Sad Farewell to Steven Gruzd

18 September 2013

At the end of this month, we will bid a sad farewell to our Senior Researcher and Political Liaison officer Steven Gruzd, who will be taking up a position at the SA Institute of International Affairs at Wits University. Steve has been with us for just over two years, although his many impressive accomplishments during [...]

[read more]